Popcorn Won’t Kill Your Colon
Keeping you out of my operating room - you can do it
Popcorn isn’t the problem - it might be the solution
For decades, patients with diverticulosis have been told to avoid popcorn, seeds, nuts, corn—basically anything small and delicious—based on the belief that these foods could lodge in diverticula and trigger diverticulitis.
Let me be very clear: that advice is outdated, unscientific, and flat-out wrong.
✅ Popcorn, Seeds, Nuts, and Corn Are Not the Problem
A landmark prospective cohort study published in JAMA followed 47,228 men over 18 years. The result? Not only was there no link between popcorn, corn, or nut consumption and diverticulitis—there was actually a lower risk among those who ate more of these foods.[¹]
And it’s not just the guys. A 2025 Annals of Internal Medicine study of nearly 30,000 women showed that nuts, seeds, and even fruits with edible seeds like raspberries were not associated with increased risk of diverticulitis either.[²]
The American Gastroenterological Association (AGA) backs this up: there is no need to avoid popcorn, nuts, or seeds if you have diverticulosis.[³] The myth should’ve died a long time ago—but here we are.
🍔 What Does Increase the Risk?
Let’s stop blaming sunflower seeds and talk about the actual offenders:
Red meat (especially unprocessed)
Refined grains
High-fat dairy
Low dietary fiber
Smoking
Obesity
Physical inactivity
Frequent use of nonaspirin NSAIDs
Alcohol dependence (moderate alcohol intake appears safe)
This Western dietary pattern increases inflammation and changes gut motility—perfect conditions for diverticulitis to thrive.
🥦 Eat Real Food. Mostly Plants. Not Too Much Meat.
Studies show that a prudent dietary pattern—rich in fruits, vegetables, whole grains, and legumes—significantly reduces the risk of diverticulitis.[⁴][⁶]
A high-fiber diet, especially one rich in fruit and cereal fiber, has been linked to a lower risk of hospitalization and recurrence.[⁴]
Physical activity helps too. In fact, vigorous exercise and maintaining a healthy weight reduce risk independently of diet. Smoking? A definite no-go.[⁵]
In one study, men who adhered to five low-risk lifestyle factors (high fiber, low red meat, regular exercise, normal BMI, and no smoking) had a 73% lower risk of diverticulitis than those who didn’t.[⁵] That’s hard to ignore.
Fiber supplements can help, but the evidence is mixed, and real food is better.[²][⁴][⁶]
🥣 What to Eat During an Active Flare (Yes, Popcorn Can Wait)
During an uncomplicated acute flare, the traditional approach is to start with a clear liquid diet—broth, gelatin, clear juices—especially if the patient has pain, anorexia, or systemic symptoms.[¹][²]
That can be advanced to a low-residue diet as symptoms improve. Patients who can’t advance their diet within 3–5 days should be evaluated for complications.
Once symptoms resolve, transitioning to a high-fiber diet is strongly recommended to prevent recurrence. Bowel rest may help acutely, but the long-term strategy is always food and fiber.
🔁 Recurrence: Common, But Preventable
About 10% to 35% of patients will have a recurrence after a first episode of uncomplicated diverticulitis, depending on the population studied and how recurrence is defined.[¹][²]
Preventing recurrence is the main goal—and both lifestyle changes and surgery play roles in that prevention strategy. Which brings us to...
🏥 When to Consider Surgery
Let’s bust another myth: elective surgery is no longer automatically recommended after a set number of recurrences.
Guidelines from the AGA and American Society of Colon and Rectal Surgeons now recommend that surgery be considered case-by-case—based on symptom severity, patient preference, complications, and overall quality of life.[²][³][⁷]
Surgery (typically sigmoid colectomy) may be appropriate for:
Recurrent or persistent symptoms that significantly impair quality of life
Complications like fistulas, strictures, or abscesses
Immunosuppressed patients at higher risk of perforation
But it’s not without risk. The DIRECT trial found that elective surgery improved quality of life—but also revealed a 15% anastomotic leak rate, and some patients still had residual symptoms.[²]
And it’s important to note: surgery does not guarantee complete relief or zero recurrence.
And remember, I’m a surgeon. I love to operate - but lets keep you out of my operating room.
⚖️ Lifestyle vs. Surgery: What Works Best?
Let’s break it down:
Lifestyle ChangesSurgeryRecurrence RiskModerately reducedSignificantly reduced (select patients)ComplicationsMinimalInfection, leak, reoperationBenefitsImproves overall healthTargeted relief in severe casesLong-Term DataObservational, some gapsSome trials, but more needed
The takeaway? Lifestyle should be first-line. It helps with diverticulitis and just about everything else. But for patients with severe, recurrent, or complicated disease, surgery can be an effective next step—with informed consent and clear expectations.
🔬 Gaps in the Evidence
We still need more high-quality, long-term head-to-head comparisons of lifestyle changes versus surgery. Most of the lifestyle data is observational, and surgical outcome studies rarely follow patients beyond a few years.
And we especially need more research on who benefits most from surgery, who doesn’t, and how to tailor post-op dietary advice to keep patients symptom-free.
🧠 Final Thoughts for Clinicians (and Curious Patients)
We’ve spent too long fearing popcorn and not enough time addressing the real risks.
✅ Popcorn, nuts, seeds, and corn are safe
❌ Red meat, inactivity, obesity, NSAIDs, and smoking increase risk
🍎 High-fiber, plant-heavy diets prevent recurrence
🥣 Clear liquids = symptom management, not long-term therapy
🔪 Surgery = an option, not a mandate
🏃♀️ Lifestyle = first-line and low-risk
Let’s stop repeating myths and start applying the data. Your gut—and your patients—will thank you.
📚 References
Strate LL, Morris AM. Epidemiology, Pathophysiology, and Treatment of Diverticulitis. Gastroenterology. 2019;156(5):1282-1298.e1.
Young-Fadok TM. Diverticulitis. N Engl J Med. 2018;379(17):1635-1642.
Peery AF, et al. AGA Clinical Practice Update. Gastroenterology. 2021;160(3):906-911.e1.
Carabotti M, et al. Dietary Habits in Diverticular Disease. Nutrients. 2021;13(4):1288.
Liu PH, et al. Healthy Lifestyle and Diverticulitis Risk. Am J Gastroenterol. 2017;112(12):1868-1876.
Feuerstein JD, Falchuk KR. Diverticulosis and Diverticulitis. Mayo Clin Proc. 2016;91(8):1094-1104.
Hall J, et al. ASCRS Guidelines for Left-Sided Colonic Diverticulitis. Dis Colon Rectum. 2020;63(6):728-747.
Dahl C, et al. Fiber and Diverticulitis Recovery. Nutrients. 2018;10(2):E137.
Barlowe T, et al. Diet and Risk in Women. Ann Intern Med. 2025.
Strate LL, et al. Nut, Corn, and Popcorn Intake and Diverticular Disease. JAMA. 2008;300(8):907-914.
Dr. Terry Simpson
Surgeon. Culinary Medicine Nerd. Your Chief Medical Explainationist.
Enjoyed this? Share with your fellow GI nerds and popcorn-phobic patients.
Subscribe to The Unfiltered MD and follow me @DrTerrySimpson on Instagram and TikTok.