Making the Perfect Turkey Breast for Thanksgiving
Every Thanksgiving, many place an enormous turkey in the oven and ask two very different muscles to cook simultaneously. The breast is lean and dries out. The legs need more time. Somehow, we’re supposed to get both right.
I’ve been cooking turkey sous vide since 2009. It changed the way I cook Thanksgiving dinner, and I’m going to show you why and how. No elaborate brining rituals, no basting, and no turkey breast that requires a gallon of gravy to make it edible.
But before we cook, there’s a fascinating story about how this bird made its way from the Americas to Europe and back again. It was the original platinum frequent flier.
Last week on FORK U we talked about eggs, and which came first. The two birds Americans eat, chicken and turkey, are next on our list for our series. And not a moment too soon.
Before we get to cooking, we need to talk about how these birds got to our dinner tables. Because the chicken and the turkey have two histories, and neither bird looks like the one our ancestors encountered.
Two Birds, Two Continents
The chicken, as we said in our last article, came from Asia. The turkey is as indigenous as my ancestors from North America. Both became important sources of animal protein.
The chicken’s ancestor is the red junglefowl, as we described in our last article.
Chickens traveled with humans. We took them on trade routes, with our armies. With Polynesians, they crossed oceans in crowded canoes, arriving in Kauai where they live, as well as other islands.
On Kauai, chickens are everywhere. They wander through parking lots, cross roads with absolutely no concern for traffic, and generally act as though the island belongs to them. And at 4 am they will wake you up. No iPhone alarm required. Also no snooze button.
The Turkey Was Already Here
Wild turkeys are native to North America, and Indigenous peoples had been hunting and domesticating them 1500 years before Europeans arrived.
The Spanish came, ate, and decided to bring Turkeys back to Europe. I cannot imagine how much fun it is to be on a 100 foot sailing vessel with a few wild turkeys roaming around. The birds were a success, as the Europeans loved this bird. And in an odd bit of re-gifting, some birds were brought back to North America with the new settlers.
The turkey had completed an Atlantic round trip before most Americans had ever heard of Thanksgiving. They were the first platinum frequent fliers.
This meant America now had three versions of the turkey. In the colonies there was the wild bird. In Mexico and the Southwest were some domesticated turkeys, and now from Europe the turkey returns (the bird, not the English) with a new attitude.
How We Built a Bigger Breast
We want birds that grow faster, have more breast meat, and are less cantankerous than the “wild” ones. Did you know the original Rodeo drive was a display of Turkey breast?
Selective breeding resulted in a turkey with a breast so large that reproduction relies on artificial insemination. Did I mention Rodeo Drive where conditions are similar?I happen to be a fan of dark, but I am in the minority. We do this because nothing says Thanksgiving, like left over turkey for a large sandwich the next day.
But the original sin, culinary sin, occurs every Thanksgiving. Thousands of unsuspecting cooks put an enormous bird into the oven. A bird with a large hole where the innards were, and expect it to cook evenly, with moist breast meat and the thighs done enough to avoid food poisoning.
The Problem With Cooking a Whole Turkey
Breast meat is lean. Now I know when you think breast, you think about a mammary gland, which is mostly fat. In turkey talk, breast meat is the pectoral muscle, not the mammary gland. Lean meat needs to be cooked differently than meat with a lot of fat in it. Think of fat as an insulation that moistens the muscle, giving a layer of protection from oven heat.
Legs and thighs contain more fat and connective tissue. The fat provides a bit of protection from heat, and the connective tissue (think gristle) breaks down under higher time and temperature, moistening the meat.
Trying to cook them simultaneously usually leads to dry breast meat, and/or undercooked thigh meat.
Most turkey recipes have elaborate rituals to try to protect the breast meat. Some advocate brining the meat in a large salt and sugar bath. If you have ever found a large tub to lower this bird in to take a salt bath, I assure you it is clumsy and not necessary. To be clear, the brine only reaches the first few millimeters of tissue and will not overcome overcooking the breast.
Then there is the injector. A large syringe, where at some odd time you inject the turkey with gravy, butter, or something to vaccinate against dryness. That doesn’t work either.
But I love the syringe, given my fear of needles when I get my yearly COVID-19 and influenza vaccine. I am convinced this is the syringe they use on me. I don’t know, I don’t look, I am a surgeon, and I fear needles (not if I use them, I can operate on you in a parking lot, but come around me with a needle and I will run screaming like a 4 year old).
Some try to protect the breast by layering butter below the turkey skin to protect that breast meat from the heat. This is marginally successful, but mostly not. Lots of people like the feeling of putting butter around everything.
Some will smoke the turkey, and those who are good at low and slow cooking, allowing lower temperatures and smoke, have marginally less dry meat, it just tastes smokey.
Then there is the all famous button that pops up on a turkey. A sort of indicator that the turkey is done and time to take it out of the oven. It sounds great, and it does not guarantee either a moist breast or an appropriately cooked thigh.
Then there is the all famous oil cooked turkey, fried. Where a turkey is lowered into a vat of oil, to cook.
Put a frozen or wet turkey into a vat of oil, and any cook will tell you what will happen. The water separates from the oil, and boils. The water and oil mix begins to pop and splatter. But in these fryers, flames fuel the oil spills over onto the fire, and now you have an oil fire. There are spectacular videos of unfortunate house and garage fires on Thanksgiving.
These are more successful because the temperature is low enough to preserve the meat, high enough to provide adequate cooking. However, too long cooking in a fryer and still the breast meat will come out dry enough that this is why gobs of gravy were invented.
There is one way to avoid all this. And it is so simple and safe. I wonder why every person who cooks doesn’t use it. It is called Sous Vide.
Sous Vide: The End of Dry Turkey Breast
I began cooking sous vide in 2009. Then it was a technique found in fine restaurants. The equipment was expensive, and hardly anyone had heard of it.
Naturally, I had to have one. My first sous vide machine cost $900 (Polyscience, I still have it and it does great). Today, you can buy the sous vide circulator for about $100. Apparently, being an early adopter comes with a substantial tax.
For those unfamiliar with sous vide, it is a method of cooking food in a bag immersed in a precisely controlled water bath. Instead of putting your turkey into a 350-degree oven and hoping you take it out before the breast becomes suitable for shoe leather, you set the water to the temperature you want the meat to reach.
The machine keeps the water at a constant temperature and circulates it. This way, the food never gets above that temperature. The outside of the breast doesn’t become overcooked while you’re waiting for the middle to finish. Given enough time, the breast, or whichever part you are cooking, reaches the uniform temperature. And that temperature is below the temperature when the meat becomes dry.
“Now why 150 degrees F, Dr. Simpson,” you wonder. “Isn’t that well below what the USDA recommends for poultry? 165F?” We kill bacteria by temperature and time. At 165 degrees, bacteria are killed, well 99.9999 percent of them, in twelve seconds. At 150 degrees F, it takes just under four minutes. Time and temperature. We can safely cook and keep the bird at 150 degrees for at least four minutes, giving time for the heat to reach the center of the mass of the meat.
The video below is one I did with my son 12, years ago. I hope you enjoy it.
For my turkey breast, I use 150°F. It has worked beautifully for years.
At one point, I was writing about sous vide cooking so much, manufacturers sent me equipment to review. I had five machines in my kitchen, they all worked well. Today I’m down to three (I have one unopened, and still have my original Polyscience from 2009). Three machines, I suppose that’s what passes for restraint in my kitchen.
How I Cook My Thanksgiving Turkey
I used to buy a whole turkey and butcher it into parts myself. These days, I simply ask the butcher for the parts I want. It’s easier, and I can buy more of the meat my family actually enjoys. My son likes any meat, his uncle likes thighs, and breasts are always a hit.
I remove the skin from the turkey breast before cooking. Save this, because this is one of the great gifts. The skin is baked separately and makes a crispy wonderful food that you can crumble into salads, or put into the stuffing.
Roll up some sage and thyme in a plastic wrap, like you are rolling a cigarette, leaving this cache open at both ends. The cache will infuse the flavor throughout the cooking time. Do not let free herbs sit in the sous vide against the chicken, or you will have some strong flavor on that part of the meat.
The breast is placed in a food-safe sous vide bag with a little olive oil and the cache of herbs. I once used a vacuum sealer for everything. Now I generally use the water-displacement method, lowering the bag into the water to push the air out.
I set my sous vide machine to 150°F. My original recipe calls for approximately two to two and a half hours, although the total time depends on how thick the breast is.
Here is the key, you will not overcook the turkey. If someone is late to dinner, you don’t have to worry that you took the turkey out of the oven too soon, and it will be cold, or that you leave it in too long and it will be dry.
Is the stuffing taking a bit longer to cook than you want? Not a worry. The Bears are going into overtime, finish the game. Sous Vide eliminates any one of a thousand things that conspires to interfere with perfect timing.
It is so simple, I wonder why anyone would want to cook turkey another way. No enormous vat of brine. No butter shoved under the skin. No elaborate rituals involving a large bird, an oven thermometer, or a syringe. No worries about a house fire.
So if you are tasked with cooking the bird, consider this method. Get a Sous VIde machine, and work it. I’d start with some chicken just to try it. Chicken breast can be moist, if you cook it sous vide. Oddly, the recipe is similar. You don’t need as much time, or you can take more time. Once you’ve seen the method, you’ll appreciate how simple it is.
Thighs
The thighs are done in the same manner, they simply need about one hour more in the Sous Vide than the breast. Just a tip, if a waitress asks you what parts you prefer and don’t preface it with the fowl, and just say I like breasts and thighs, you might get an odd look. Don’t ask me how I know that.
My Mother’s Approval
The first time I made the turkey sous vide, my mother was skeptical. This was not how she had cooked turkey, and she wasn’t particularly convinced that a strange machine heating water would improve Thanksgiving dinner.
She approved of the turkey. Getting my mother’s approval for anything in the kitchen was a rare event. That made this particular Thanksgiving memorable.
Thanksgiving Without Five Days of Leftovers
Here’s another trick I’ve learned.
Cook the turkey breast, serve half for Thanksgiving, and freeze the other half. Chill it promptly and freeze it in a sealed bag. When you want turkey again, you can gently reheat it using the sous vide machine. Allow enough time for the center to heat thoroughly, particularly if you’re starting with a frozen piece.
You don’t have to spend the next five days inventing increasingly desperate ways to use leftover turkey.
Of course, my calculations have changed a little. JJ is sixteen now, and the amount of turkey required for Thanksgiving is not what it used to be.
I hope that someday I’ll be cooking Thanksgiving dinner for JJ, his friends, perhaps his own family, grandchildren, and whoever he chooses to share his life with. I envision they’ll all gather around the table, and the one thing they’ll agree upon is that the turkey breast is moist.
Of course, when JJ leaves for college, I expect I’ll need at least a day or two to recover from empty-nest syndrome. Then I can move into a smaller condo on the water. He’ll come home for Thanksgiving and wonder why his bedroom has been replaced with a pull-out couch, and why his dorm room is full of all the things I didn’t want to keep.
But he’ll always have a place at my Thanksgiving table. And the turkey breast will never be dry.
The Rest of Thanksgiving Dinner
And since we’ve spent all this time talking about how to avoid overcooking the turkey, here are a few of my favorite side dishes. The story continues. Become a paid subscriber for the rest of Thanksgiving dinner, including my favorite side dishes, and kitchen tricks to make the holiday easier. And to everyone who reads and supports this, thank you.


